Gluten-Free Redo

Flour Power

A guide to gluten-free all-purpose baking blends
Flour Power

In VT’s latest baking experiment, we tried seven different gluten-free flour mixes in three basic recipes for blueberry muffins, banana pancakes, and chocolate-chip cookies. The takeaway? All the mixes were good, but the best choice mostly depends on personal preference and what you’re planning to make.

Read on for a brand-by-brand report.

Arrowhead Mills Gluten Free All Purpose Baking Mix
This blend contains baking powder to lighten baked goods.

muffin results: Firm, moist, smallish muffins with flat tops; thick batter needed extra baking time.
pancake results: Pale, crisp pancakes that rose moderately and cooked evenly.
cookie results: Puffy and crunchy cookies on the outside, tender and buttery inside.

Better Batter All Purpose Flour Mix
The box says to add extra liquid to yeast doughs; we did the same for batters.

muffin results: Tender, chewy, smallish muffins with rounded tops.
pancake results: Pretty, perfectly round pancakes that browned quickly and were slightly chewy.
cookie results: Cookies looked more like nuggets, but they had a melt-in-your-mouth texture like gourmet bakery cookies.

Bob’s Red Mill All Purpose GF Baking Flour
Unlike most mixes, this is primarily garbanzo bean flour. (Package recommends adding xanthan gum, but we did not.)

muffin results: Thin batter; produced smaller muffins with flat tops and slightly nutty taste.
pancake results: Smooth, chewy pancakes that browned evenly and had a buttery flavor.
cookie results: Crisp cookies with caramel-like flavor from a dough that spread quickly in the oven.

Fearn Rice Baking Mix
Baking powder, baking soda, and salt in this rice flour/soya powder mix make it more like self-rising flour. (We left out leavening agents in recipes.)

muffin results: Flat-topped, quick-browning muffins with a crumbly texture.
pancake results: Thick, fluffy pancakes that browned quickly in the pan.
cookie results: Not recommended for cookies.

Gluten Free Pantry Gluten-Free All-Purpose Flour
This basic blend produces results closest to all-purpose wheat flour.

muffin results: Tall, round-topped muffins with a tender texture.
pancake results: Pale-colored, thick pancakes that were dense and chewy. Batter had to be thinned with water.
cookie results: Dough spread a lot when baked and yielded thin, crunchy cookies.

King Arthur Gluten Free Multi-Purpose Flour
Without guar or xanthan gums, this blend makes thin batters and soft doughs.

muffin results: Round-topped muffins with a fine, dense crumb.
pancake results: Thin pancakes that were crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with a buttery-sweet flavor.
cookie results: Flat, crisp cookies that were somewhat fragile.

Namaste Perfect Flour Blend
This mix of brown rice, tapioca, arrowroot, and sorghum flours and xanthan gum makes thick batters and doughs.

muffin results: Slightly lumpy batter produced crumbly topped, moist muffins.
pancake results: Not recommended for pancakes.
cookie results: Tender, puffy cookies that were almost meringue-like.

December 2011 p.42

get the recipes

Gluten-Free Blueberry Muffins

Gluten-Free Blueberry Muffins

Food editor Mary Margaret Chappell used this recipe to test the gluten-free flour blends featured in VT’s brand by brand comparison (‘"Flour Power," December 2011, p. 42).

more

Gluten-Free Banana Pancakes

Food editor Mary Margaret Chappell used this recipe to test the gluten-free flour blends featured in VT’s brand by brand comparison (‘"Flour Power," December 2011, p. 42).

more

Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookies

Not Yet Rated

Food editor Mary Margaret Chappell used this recipe to test the gluten-free flour blends featured in VT’s brand by brand comparison (‘"Flour Power," December 2011, p. 42).

more

you might also like



comments

I made the muffins per your recipe using BRM's All Purpose Flour and added xanthan gum per instructions on the side of the flour pkg... results were thick batter, high muffins with rounded tops that were very delicious!!

Linda Roderigues - 2012-10-03 17:12:59

This is a great little article; I'm always on the lookout for helpful comparisons such as these. There's a new blend in some select markets that I would highly recommend: Deya's Gluten Free Flour. It's a 1 to 1 replacement flour and is the best I've tried thus far for my favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe, and I've tried just about all of the choices highlighted in this article. These are good, but Deya's is better. Her's can be found at "www.deyasglutenfree.com". Hope this is helpful.

Patricia - 2012-10-03 15:21:21